🎠Why We Often Misjudge Our Risk Tolerance
One of the most common questions in investing is:
"What's your risk tolerance?"
At first glance, the question seems simple.
How much risk are you comfortable taking?
Most of us have an answer.
The challenge is that research suggests we aren't always very good at predicting how we'll actually respond when risk becomes real.
In other words:
There is often a difference between our perceived risk tolerance and our actual risk tolerance.
What Is Risk Tolerance?
Risk tolerance is your ability and willingness to withstand uncertainty and temporary losses in pursuit of long-term returns.
Notice there are two parts to that definition:
Financial Ability
Can your financial plan withstand market volatility?
For example:
-
Do you have an emergency fund?
-
How stable is your income?
-
How many years until retirement?
-
How much debt do you carry?
Emotional Ability
Can you emotionally tolerate seeing your investments decline without abandoning your plan?
This second part is where things get interesting.
The Problem With Predicting Ourselves
Psychologists have spent decades studying something called affective forecasting.
Affective forecasting refers to our ability to predict how we will feel in future situations.
The research consistently shows that humans are not particularly good at it.
We often overestimate or underestimate our future emotional reactions.
For example:
People may believe:
"If the market dropped 30%, I would stay calm."
That sounds reasonable when the market is doing well.
But when a portfolio actually declines by tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars, emotions often become much stronger than anticipated.
The risk isn't theoretical anymore.
It's personal.
What the Research Shows
One of the most fascinating findings from market downturns is how investors behave differently than they predicted they would.
During significant market declines, many investors who previously described themselves as aggressive investors suddenly wanted to move to cash.
Not because their financial goals changed.
Not because their retirement timeline changed.
But because their emotional experience changed.
The pain of losses felt greater than they anticipated.
Behavioral economists call this loss aversion.
Research by psychologists Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky found that losses generally feel approximately twice as painful as equivalent gains feel pleasurable.
In simple terms:
Losing $10,000 often feels worse than gaining $10,000 feels good.
This helps explain why investors may react emotionally during downturns even when they understand markets are behaving normally.
A Nurse Example
Imagine two nurses.
Both complete a risk tolerance questionnaire.
Both identify as aggressive investors.
Both say they could tolerate a 30% market decline.
Then a bear market occurs.
Nurse A sees her portfolio decline from $100,000 to $70,000.
She feels uncomfortable but continues investing.
Nurse B sees the same decline and immediately wants to sell everything.
What happened?
Their actual risk tolerance turned out to be different from what they initially believed.
The market didn't reveal anything new about investing.
It revealed something new about themselves.
Why Experience Matters
One reason risk tolerance often changes over time is because experience provides information that questionnaires cannot.
Before you've lived through a significant market decline, your answers are largely hypothetical.
After you've lived through one, your answers become grounded in reality.
This is one reason many financial planners say that risk tolerance isn't something you discover once.
It's something you learn about yourself over time.
The Goal Isn't Maximum Risk
A common misconception is that successful investors should always take as much risk as possible.
Behavioral finance suggests otherwise.
The "best" portfolio isn't necessarily the one with the highest expected return.
It's often the portfolio you can stick with during difficult periods.
Because even the most sophisticated investment strategy won't help if fear causes you to abandon it during a downturn.
What I've Observed
Some of the most successful long-term investors aren't the people with the highest risk tolerance.
They're the people who understand their risk tolerance.
They know how they'll likely react during volatility.
They build portfolios they can stay invested in.
And they recognize that managing emotions is often just as important as selecting investments.
NurseMoneyDate® Takeaway
One of the most valuable things a market downturn can teach us isn't about stocks.
It's about ourselves.
Risk tolerance isn't measured when markets are rising.
It's revealed when markets are falling.
And sometimes the greatest financial lesson isn't learning what the market will do next.
It's learning how we will respond when it does.